Specific Carbohydrate (SCD) Diet vs GAPS Diet

When it comes to managing digestive issues, two diets have gained significant popularity among health enthusiasts and those seeking relief from these ailments: the Specific Carbohydrate Diet (SCD) and the Gut and Psychology Syndrome (GAPS) diet. In this article, we'll explore the ins and outs of these two diets, examining their similarities, differences, benefits, and drawbacks to help you make an informed decision about which one may be right for you.

Introduction to SCD and GAPS diets

The SCD and GAPS diets are both focused on healing the digestive system to improve overall health. The diets have their roots in the work of Dr. Sidney V. Haas and Dr. Natasha Campbell-McBride, respectively. Dr. Haas developed the SCD in the 1920s as a treatment for celiac disease and other digestive disorders, while Dr. Campbell-McBride created the GAPS diet in the early 2000s as a way to treat conditions related to gut health, including autism, ADHD, and depression.

Both diets emphasize the importance of eliminating processed foods, grains, and sugars, and instead focusing on nutrient-dense whole foods. The SCD diet is more restrictive, allowing only certain fruits, vegetables, meats, and homemade yogurt, while the GAPS diet includes a wider variety of foods such as nuts, seeds, and fermented foods. Both diets also encourage the use of bone broth, which is rich in nutrients that support gut health.

Understanding the Specific Carbohydrate Diet (SCD)

The SCD diet is a strict protocol that eliminates all complex carbohydrates from the diet. This includes grains, potatoes, and most fruits and vegetables. The diet also eliminates processed foods, sugars, and lactose-containing dairy products. Instead, the diet focuses on simple carbohydrates, such as honey and fruit juice, and encourages the consumption of meat, fish, eggs, and non-starchy vegetables.

The SCD diet was originally developed to help manage symptoms of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), such as Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis. The theory behind the diet is that by eliminating complex carbohydrates, which are difficult to digest, the gut can heal and inflammation can be reduced. Some studies have shown that the SCD diet can be effective in reducing symptoms and improving quality of life for those with IBD.

However, it is important to note that the SCD diet is not suitable for everyone. It can be difficult to follow and may not provide enough nutrients for some individuals. It is important to consult with a healthcare professional before starting the SCD diet, especially if you have a medical condition or are taking medication.

The GAPS diet: what it is and how it works

Somewhat similar to the SCD diet, the GAPS diet also eliminates grains, processed foods, and sugars. It also eliminates dairy products, but the diet is a bit more flexible in terms of carbohydrates, allowing for the consumption of some starchy vegetables and fruits. The GAPS diet also incorporates bone broth and fermented foods to support gut health and healing.

The GAPS diet was developed by Dr. Natasha Campbell-McBride, a neurologist and nutritionist, to address gut-related health issues such as leaky gut syndrome, autism, and ADHD. The diet is based on the idea that many health problems stem from an imbalance of gut bacteria, and that by healing the gut, overall health can be improved.

While the GAPS diet can be effective for some people, it is important to note that it is a restrictive diet and may not be suitable for everyone. It is always recommended to consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new diet or making significant changes to your current diet.

Similarities between SCD and GAPS diets

While there are some differences between the SCD and GAPS diets, there are also many similarities. Both diets emphasize the elimination of processed foods and sugars, as well as the consumption of nutrient-dense whole foods, including animal protein and non-starchy vegetables. Both diets also stress the importance of supporting gut health to promote overall health and wellbeing.

Additionally, both diets recommend the incorporation of fermented foods, such as sauerkraut and kefir, to promote the growth of beneficial gut bacteria. Both diets also suggest the use of bone broth, which is rich in nutrients and can help heal the gut lining. Finally, both diets encourage individuals to listen to their bodies and make adjustments as needed to find what works best for them.

Differences between SCD and GAPS diets

The biggest difference between the SCD and GAPS diets is the elimination of starchy vegetables and fruits in the SCD, which may limit the variety of foods available to those following the diet. Additionally, the GAPS diet is more flexible in terms of carbohydrate consumption, allowing for a wider variety of foods. Another primary difference between the two diets is the incorporation of fermented foods in the GAPS diet, which may offer additional digestive and immune system benefits.

Another difference between the SCD and GAPS diets is the recommended duration of the introductory phase. The SCD diet recommends a minimum of 2-5 days for the introductory phase, while the GAPS diet recommends a minimum of 6 months. This longer introductory phase in the GAPS diet may be more challenging for some individuals to adhere to, but it may also provide more time for the gut to heal and for symptoms to improve.

Health benefits of the SCD diet

The SCD diet has been shown to improve symptoms and promote healing in individuals with digestive disorders, including celiac disease, Crohn's disease, and ulcerative colitis. The diet may also be effective in managing symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and improving overall gut health. The elimination of processed foods and sugars in the SCD diet may also lead to improved weight management and decreased risk of chronic diseases such as diabetes and heart disease.

Health benefits of the GAPS diet

The GAPS diet has been shown to be effective in treating a wide range of health conditions related to gut health, including autoimmune disorders, ADHD, and depression. The incorporation of fermented foods and bone broth in the diet may also help improve immune function and support overall health.

Who should try the SCD diet?

The SCD diet is an effective protocol for individuals with digestive disorders such as celiac disease, Crohn's disease, and ulcerative colitis. It may also be helpful in managing symptoms of IBS and improving overall gut health.

Who should try the GAPS diet?

The GAPS diet may be beneficial for individuals with a wide range of health conditions related to gut health, including autoimmune disorders, ADHD, and depression. The diet may also be effective in managing digestive disorders and improving overall gut health.

How to follow the SCD diet: a step-by-step guide

The SCD diet is a strict protocol that requires the elimination of all complex carbohydrates from the diet. It is recommended to work with a healthcare practitioner or registered dietitian familiar with the diet to ensure proper nutrient intake and avoid nutrient deficiencies. It is also important to gradually reintroduce foods after an elimination phase to gauge tolerance.

How to follow the GAPS diet: a step-by-step guide

The GAPS diet is a bit more flexible than the SCD diet but still requires the elimination of processed foods, sugars, and grains. It is recommended to follow the diet for at least two years to allow for improved gut healing and function. It is also important to incorporate bone broth and fermented foods to support gut health.

Recipes for the Specific Carbohydrate Diet

There are many delicious recipes available that comply with the SCD diet, including recipes for baked goods, soups, and main dishes. Some popular recipes include almond flour pancakes, coconut flour bread, and roasted chicken with vegetables.

Recipes for the GAPS Diet

The GAPS diet allows for a wider variety of foods than the SCD diet, and there are many delicious recipes available to enjoy while following the protocol. Some popular recipes include homemade sauerkraut, bone broth soup, and roasted chicken with carrots and onions.

Pros and cons of following the SCD diet

One of the biggest pros of following the SCD diet is improved digestive function and symptom relief for individuals with digestive disorders. The diet may also lead to improved weight management and decreased risk of chronic disease. However, the strict protocol may limit food variety and require careful planning and preparation to meet nutrient needs.

Pros and cons of following the GAPS diet

The GAPS diet may offer a wide range of benefits, including improved gut health, immune function, and relief of symptoms for individuals with various health conditions. The incorporation of bone broth and fermented foods may also offer additional health benefits. However, the diet may be challenging to follow in terms of food variety and require careful planning to meet nutrient needs.

Which diet is better? A comparison of effectiveness

While the SCD and GAPS diets share many similarities, they also have some key differences. The SCD diet may be more effective for individuals with digestive disorders, while the GAPS diet may offer a wider range of benefits for those with various health conditions. Ultimately, the effectiveness of each diet may depend on individual needs, preferences, and goals.

Frequently asked questions about SCD and GAPS diets

Q: What is the difference between SCD and GAPS diets?
A: While both diets emphasize the elimination of processed foods and sugars and the consumption of whole, nutrient-dense foods, the SCD diet eliminates all complex carbohydrates, while the GAPS diet is more flexible in terms of carbohydrate consumption, allowing for the consumption of some starchy vegetables and fruits. Additionally, the GAPS diet incorporates bone broth and fermented foods to support gut health.

Q: Are SCD and GAPS diets good for weight loss?
A: Both diets may be helpful for weight management due to the focus on whole foods and the elimination of processed foods and sugars. However, ensuring adequate nutrient intake and balanced meals is crucial for long-term weight management and overall health.

Q: Can I follow the SCD or GAPS diet if I am vegetarian or vegan?
A: The SCD and GAPS diets are primarily focused on animal protein and non-starchy vegetables, making it challenging to follow as a vegetarian or vegan. However, modifications can be made to meet individual needs and preferences.

Q: Is the SCD or GAPS diet safe for children?
A: Both diets can be safe for children with appropriate modifications and guidance from a healthcare practitioner or registered dietitian. However, it is important to ensure adequate nutrient intake for growing children.

Conclusion

The SCD and GAPS diets are both effective protocols for improving gut health and overall health. While they share many similarities, there are also some key differences to consider. Speak to a healthcare practitioner or registered dietitian to determine which diet may be best for you based on your individual needs, preferences, and health goals.